The Financial Times article:
Cisco and
Ericsson want to build what they call “networks of the
future”, although will initially focus on selling telecoms
customers joint portfolios of products and services in mobility and
intellectual property networking. The companies say they will
generate $1bn in additional revenue each by 2018.
But some analysts were unconvinced, with one suggesting
that the deal was a defensive move in response to the tie-up
between Nokia and Alcatel.
Pierre Ferragu at Bernstein said the near-term benefits of
the deal would be “merely about reselling and are likely to
benefit Cisco”.
He added: “Longer term both partners could benefit
on a wider scale, but this would require collaboration to be
successful in product development, which is far from
guaranteed.”
Mr Chambers, a veteran deal maker who made more than 180
acquisitions while chief executive of Cisco, said the partnership
would lead to the companies developing new technology and services
and is the new model for the once-acquisitive group. “This
will be as important in the next decade as M&A has been in the
past two decades,” he said.
He played down the benefits of a full merger, saying that
partnership with Ericsson means that the companies can avoid the
need to restructure or go through regulatory processes.
The odds are good that [the Alcatel and Nokia merger]
will fail
- John Chambers
Tweet this
quote
“The odds are good that [the Alcatel and Nokia
merger] will fail,” he said, pointing to previous examples of
large technology mergers that have struggled. “By the time
you shake out the efficiencies and get regulatory approval,
it’s a two- to three-year process. This industry, the winners
and losers, will be decided in three years. I’d love to see a
lot of our peers tied up with large acquisitions.”
Mr Chambers pointed to the disastrous combination of
Alcatel and Lucent in 2006 as a “gift from
heaven”.
Nokia dismissed Mr Chamber’s comments, saying:
“The integrated sales team of the new Nokia will look forward
to pitching against a Cisco salesperson selling Ericsson
products.”
Cisco and Ericsson both provide telecoms network equipment
but operate in different segments.
Analysts at CCS Insight said: “The deal will allow
the companies to cross-license patents, share development costs and
expand their portfolios as customers require improved network
management and look for new opportunities in connecting
things.”
Cisco approached the partnership with Ericsson as it would
have done a full merger. The companies have been working on forming
an agreement for 13 months, with teams on both sides spending 2,000
hours in meetings to get the deal done.
Mr Chambers said he and Hans Vestberg, chief executive of
Ericsson, now “finish each other’s
sentences”.